ChainScore Labs
All Guides

Comparing DEXs for Yield Farming: Uniswap, SushiSwap, PancakeSwap

LABS

Comparing DEXs for Yield Farming: Uniswap, SushiSwap, PancakeSwap

A technical guide to selecting the optimal Automated Market Maker for liquidity provision and yield farming strategies.
Chainscore © 2025

Foundational Concepts for DEX Comparison

Key metrics and mechanisms to evaluate when choosing a Decentralized Exchange for yield farming, focusing on Uniswap, SushiSwap, and PancakeSwap.

Automated Market Maker (AMM) Model

Automated Market Makers are the core protocol that powers DEX liquidity pools, using mathematical formulas to set prices instead of order books.

  • Uses a constant product formula (x*y=k) to manage pool ratios and pricing.
  • Uniswap V3 introduced concentrated liquidity, allowing LPs to set custom price ranges for capital efficiency.
  • This matters as it determines trading fees, slippage, and the fundamental yield generation mechanics for liquidity providers.

Liquidity Provider (LP) Tokens & Rewards

LP Tokens are receipt tokens issued to users who deposit assets into a pool, representing their share and enabling yield farming.

  • Tokens can be staked in separate farm contracts to earn additional protocol tokens (e.g., SUSHI, CAKE).
  • SushiSwap's Onsen program frequently offers high APY on new and popular token pairs to attract liquidity.
  • This is crucial as it defines the dual-layered yield: trading fees from the pool plus extra token incentives.

Governance & Tokenomics

Governance tokens (UNI, SUSHI, CAKE) confer voting rights and influence over protocol upgrades, fee structures, and treasury funds.

  • SushiSwap uses a revenue-sharing model, directing a portion of trading fees to xSUSHI stakers.
  • PancakeSwap's CAKE has aggressive token burns and flexible staking pools to manage inflation and reward long-term holders.
  • This impacts long-term sustainability and the value accrual of the rewards you earn from farming.

Multi-Chain Deployment & Fees

The underlying blockchain and associated gas fees critically affect farming profitability and accessibility for users.

  • Uniswap is primarily on Ethereum mainnet (high gas) and Layer 2s like Arbitrum for lower costs.
  • PancakeSwap dominates on BNB Chain, offering significantly lower transaction fees, making small-scale farming viable.
  • This determines the net profit from yield farming after accounting for transaction costs for deposits, claims, and withdrawals.

Impermanent Loss (IL) Risk

Impermanent Loss is the potential loss a liquidity provider faces compared to simply holding assets, caused by price volatility within the pool.

  • IL is higher for volatile token pairs (e.g., ETH/altcoin) versus stable pairs (e.g., USDC/USDT).
  • Uniswap V3's concentrated liquidity can amplify IL if the price moves outside your set range.
  • Understanding IL is essential for risk management; high yield rewards often compensate for this inherent risk.

Protocol Architecture & Feature Matrix

Comparison of key technical and feature differences for yield farming on leading DEXs

FeatureUniswap (V3)SushiSwapPancakeSwap

Primary Chain

Ethereum

Ethereum, Arbitrum, Polygon, etc.

BNB Chain

Automated Market Maker (AMM) Model

Concentrated Liquidity (V3)

Constant Product AMM (V2 fork)

Constant Product AMM (V2 fork)

Native Governance Token

UNI

SUSHI

CAKE

Yield Farming Rewards

Limited (primarily fee-based)

SUSHI emissions via Onsen

High CAKE emissions via Syrup Pools

Fee Structure for LPs

0.05%, 0.30%, 1.00% tiers

0.25% standard (0.05% to xSUSHI holders)

0.25% standard (0.02% to treasury)

Impermanent Loss Protection

No

No (historically proposed)

Yes (via PancakeSwap v3 Lottery & Predictions)

Multi-chain Deployment

Ethereum, Polygon, Arbitrum, etc.

Over 30 chains via SushiXSwap

BNB Chain, Ethereum, Aptos, etc.

Built-in DEX Aggregator

No (but has Router)

Yes (via SushiXSwap)

Yes (via PancakeSwap Swap & Perpetuals)

Yield Farming Strategy Implementation

A structured process for comparing and selecting the optimal DEX for yield farming based on liquidity, fees, and rewards.

1

Research and Compare DEX Fundamentals

Analyze core protocol metrics and tokenomics to establish a baseline for comparison.

Detailed Instructions

Begin by conducting a fundamental analysis of each DEX. This involves examining the total value locked (TVL), trading volume, and the security of the underlying smart contracts. For example, Uniswap V3 on Ethereum mainnet currently holds the largest TVL, while PancakeSwap on BNB Chain often offers lower transaction fees.

  • Sub-step 1: Gather Protocol Data: Use DeFi Llama or the protocol's own analytics dashboards to record current TVL, daily volume, and number of active pools for Uniswap, SushiSwap, and PancakeSwap.
  • Sub-step 2: Analyze Tokenomics: Investigate the native token's utility (e.g., UNI for governance, SUSHI for fee-sharing, CAKE for farming rewards) and its emission/inflation schedule.
  • Sub-step 3: Assess Security: Review audit reports from firms like CertiK or OpenZeppelin and check for any major historical exploits on platforms like Rekt.news.

Tip: Prioritize protocols with consistent high TVL, transparent tokenomics, and a strong track record of security audits for reduced risk.

2

Evaluate Specific Farming Pools and APYs

Identify and compare the potential returns from available liquidity pools across the selected DEXs.

Detailed Instructions

Focus on finding pools with sustainable and attractive Annual Percentage Yields (APYs). Remember that displayed APYs are dynamic and consist of trading fees and often additional token rewards. A pool like ETH/USDC will exist on all three DEXs, but the returns will differ.

  • Sub-step 1: Identify Target Pairs: Decide on the asset pairs you wish to provide liquidity for (e.g., stablecoin pairs, blue-chip pairs, or newer altcoins).
  • Sub-step 2: Compare Real-Time APYs: Use yield aggregators like Yieldwatch or Apeboard to view APYs for the same pair across different DEXs. For instance, CAKE/BNB on PancakeSwap might show 45% APY, while SUSHI/ETH on SushiSwap shows 28%.
  • Sub-step 3: Analyze Reward Composition: Determine what portion of the yield comes from fees versus inflationary token emissions. High emissions can lead to token price depreciation.

Tip: Be wary of pools with excessively high APYs (>100%), as they often involve high-risk assets or unsustainable token emissions that may not be profitable after impermanent loss.

3

Calculate Costs and Impermanent Loss (IL) Scenarios

Model the financial impact of transaction fees and potential impermanent loss for your chosen pools.

Detailed Instructions

Impermanent loss is the potential loss compared to simply holding the assets, which occurs when the price ratio of the paired tokens changes. You must also factor in gas fees on Ethereum versus lower fees on BNB Chain or Layer 2s.

  • Sub-step 1: Simulate Impermanent Loss: Use an online IL calculator. Input your assets, like 1 ETH ($3,000) and 3,000 USDC, and simulate a 50% price increase for ETH. The calculator will show the IL as a percentage of your initial value.
  • Sub-step 2: Estimate Total Fee Costs: Calculate the cost to approve, deposit, harvest rewards, and withdraw. On Ethereum, this could cost $50-$200, while on BNB Chain it might be under $1.
  • Sub-step 3: Run Break-Even Analysis: Determine how long you need to farm to cover the initial deposit fees with earned yield. Use the formula: Break-Even Days = Total Fee Cost / (Daily Yield in USD).
code
// Example IL calculation logic (conceptual) function calculateIL(priceRatioChange) { // Simplified formula: IL = 2 * sqrt(priceRatio) / (1 + priceRatio) - 1 return 2 * Math.sqrt(priceRatioChange) / (1 + priceRatioChange) - 1; } // A 2x price change (priceRatioChange = 2) results in ~5.7% IL.

Tip: Stablecoin pairs (e.g., USDC/USDT) experience minimal IL but offer lower yields, making them ideal for beginners or conservative strategies.

4

Execute Deposit and Monitor Strategy

Implement the chosen strategy by providing liquidity and setting up active management protocols.

Detailed Instructions

After selecting the optimal DEX and pool, proceed to deposit liquidity. This requires interacting directly with the protocol's smart contracts, typically through its web interface. Ensure you have the correct network (e.g., Ethereum Mainnet for Uniswap, BNB Smart Chain for PancakeSwap) configured in your wallet like MetaMask.

  • Sub-step 1: Approve Token Spending: For each token in the pair, you must approve the DEX's router contract to spend your tokens. For Uniswap V3, the router address is 0xE592427A0AEce92De3Edee1F18E0157C05861564.
  • Sub-step 2: Add Liquidity: Deposit an equal value of both tokens. On SushiSwap, you would navigate to the 'Pool' section, select your tokens and amounts, and confirm the transaction.
  • Sub-step 3: Stake LP Tokens for Rewards: Often, you must stake the received LP tokens (e.g., SLP tokens for SushiSwap) in a separate farm to earn the extra protocol rewards. On PancakeSwap, you would go to the 'Farms' section to stake your CAKE-LP tokens.
  • Sub-step 4: Set Up Monitoring: Use a portfolio tracker like DeBank or Zapper to monitor your position's value, accrued rewards, and IL in real-time. Consider setting up price alerts for your asset pair.

Tip: For active management on Uniswap V3, you may need to adjust your liquidity concentration range periodically based on market volatility to maximize fee income.

Strategy Perspectives by User Profile

Getting Started with Yield Farming

Yield farming is the process of earning rewards by providing liquidity to a decentralized exchange (DEX). Think of it like earning interest by depositing your crypto assets into a pool that traders use. For a beginner, the key is to start simple and understand the risks.

Key Points to Consider

  • Impermanent Loss: This occurs when the price of your deposited tokens changes compared to when you deposited them. You might earn fees but lose value on your initial deposit. Starting with stablecoin pairs on PancakeSwap can minimize this risk.
  • APY (Annual Percentage Yield): This is the advertised return rate. High APYs on SushiSwap or Uniswap can be tempting but often come with higher volatility and risk. Always check if the rate is sustainable.
  • Gas Fees: On Ethereum-based DEXs like Uniswap, transaction fees can be high. PancakeSwap on BNB Chain typically has much lower fees, making it more accessible for small investments.

Practical First Step

When starting on Uniswap, you would first connect your wallet (like MetaMask), navigate to the 'Pool' tab, and select a popular pair like ETH/USDC. After depositing an equal value of both tokens, you receive LP (Liquidity Provider) tokens, which represent your share of the pool and accrue trading fees.

SECTION-RISK-FAQ

Risk Analysis & Common Pitfalls

Ready to Start Building?

Let's bring your Web3 vision to life.

From concept to deployment, ChainScore helps you architect, build, and scale secure blockchain solutions.