How to Simulate Portfolio Changes Before Executing

LABS

How to Simulate Portfolio Changes Before Executing

Core Concepts of Portfolio Simulation

Learn how to model and analyze potential portfolio adjustments using hypothetical scenarios, enabling data-driven investment decisions without real-world risk.

Scenario Analysis

Scenario Analysis involves modeling portfolio performance under different hypothetical market conditions. This forward-looking approach allows investors to stress-test their strategies against various economic futures.

What-if modeling for events like interest rate hikes or recessions
Creating best-case, worst-case, and base-case projections to gauge potential outcomes
For example, simulating how a 60/40 stock/bond portfolio would have fared during the 2008 financial crisis
This matters because it helps investors understand potential risks and prepare contingency plans before market shifts occur.

Monte Carlo Simulation

Monte Carlo Simulation uses random sampling and statistical modeling to estimate the probability of different portfolio outcomes over time. It accounts for the inherent uncertainty and randomness of financial markets.

Runs thousands of randomized trials based on historical return distributions and volatility
Generates a probability distribution of potential future portfolio values, not just a single forecast
A practical use case is estimating the likelihood of a retirement portfolio lasting 30 years given certain withdrawal rates
This is crucial for investors as it quantifies risk and helps set realistic expectations for long-term goals.

Asset Correlation Modeling

Asset Correlation Modeling examines how different investments in a portfolio move in relation to one another. Understanding these relationships is key to building a diversified portfolio that can withstand market volatility.

Measures the correlation coefficient between asset classes (e.g., stocks vs. bonds, which are often negatively correlated)
Allows simulation of how adding an uncorrelated asset like gold or real estate can reduce overall portfolio risk
For instance, testing if international equities provide better diversification than domestic ones during a domestic market downturn
This matters for users because effective diversification is the primary method to reduce unsystematic risk without sacrificing returns.

Rebalancing Strategy Simulation

Rebalancing Strategy Simulation tests different rules and schedules for adjusting portfolio allocations back to their target weights. This process is critical for maintaining a desired risk level and potentially enhancing returns.

Compares time-based (e.g., quarterly) vs. threshold-based (e.g., when an asset drifts 5% from target) rebalancing methods
Models the tax implications and transaction costs associated with each rebalancing action
A real example is simulating whether a 5% threshold strategy outperforms an annual calendar rebalance for a taxable account
This is vital for users to implement a disciplined, cost-effective strategy that systematically buys low and sells high.

Liquidity & Cash Flow Modeling

Liquidity & Cash Flow Modeling projects the future inflows and outflows of capital within a portfolio. It ensures the portfolio can meet expected and unexpected expenses without forcing the sale of assets at inopportune times.

Forecasts regular contributions, dividends, and withdrawals against simulated market returns
Stress-tests the portfolio's ability to fund a major expense, like a home down payment, during a market downturn
An example is modeling a retirement income strategy that includes systematic withdrawals from a balanced portfolio
This matters for users to avoid sequence-of-returns risk and maintain financial stability through all market cycles.

A Practical Simulation Workflow

A step-by-step guide to safely modeling portfolio changes using a test environment before executing on mainnet.

Step 1: Establish a Local Test Environment

Set up a controlled, isolated blockchain replica for safe experimentation.

Detailed Instructions

Begin by creating a local fork of the target blockchain using a development framework like Hardhat or Foundry. This creates a sandboxed environment that mirrors the live network's state at a specific block, allowing you to interact with real smart contracts without spending gas or risking funds. Forking the mainnet is crucial for accurate simulation, as it replicates token balances, contract states, and DeFi protocol interactions.

Sub-step 1: Install and initialize your chosen framework (e.g., npm init hardhat).
Sub-step 2: Configure the network fork in your hardhat.config.js file to point to a node provider like Alchemy or Infura.
Sub-step 3: Specify the block number to fork from (e.g., block 19283746) to ensure a consistent state for all simulations.
Sub-step 4: Fund your local test accounts with simulated ETH using the hardhat_setBalance RPC method.

Tip: Use a node provider with archive data access to fork from any historical block, ensuring your simulation's starting point is reproducible.

javascript
// hardhat.config.js network configuration
module.exports = {
  networks: {
    hardhat: {
      forking: {
        url: "https://eth-mainnet.alchemyapi.io/v2/YOUR_API_KEY",
        blockNumber: 19283746
      }
    }
  }
};

Step 2: Script the Portfolio Interaction

Write and parameterize the transaction sequence you intend to simulate.

Detailed Instructions

Develop a deterministic simulation script that encodes the exact series of transactions you plan to execute. This involves interacting with smart contract interfaces for protocols like Uniswap V3 (0xE592427A0AEce92De3Edee1F18E0157C05861564) or Aave V3 (0x87870Bca3F3fD6335C3F4ce8392D69350B4fA4E2). Parameterize all inputs—such as swap amounts, slippage tolerance, and liquidity positions—so you can easily adjust and re-run the simulation. Use your framework's testing utilities to impersonate accounts and sign transactions.

Sub-step 1: Import the necessary contract ABIs and connect to the forked network's provider.
Sub-step 2: Define the exact transaction flow, e.g., approve WETH, swap 10 ETH for USDC, then deposit USDC into a lending pool.
Sub-step 3: Set up event listeners to capture key outcomes like token balance changes or pool share minting.
Sub-step 4: Include console.log statements or write results to a file for later analysis.

Tip: Store sensitive parameters like private keys and API keys in environment variables (e.g., a .env file) to keep your script secure and portable.

javascript
// Example Hardhat script snippet
const { ethers } = require("hardhat");
async function simulateSwap() {
  const [signer] = await ethers.getSigners();
  const uniswapRouter = new ethers.Contract("0xE592427A0AEce92De3Edee1F18E0157C05861564", abi, signer);
  const amountIn = ethers.utils.parseEther("10"); // 10 ETH
  await uniswapRouter.exactInputSingle({
    tokenIn: "0xC02aaA39b223FE8D0A0e5C4F27eAD9083C756Cc2",
    tokenOut: "0xA0b86991c6218b36c1d19D4a2e9Eb0cE3606eB48",
    fee: 3000,
    recipient: signer.address,
    deadline: Math.floor(Date.now() / 1000) + 1800,
    amountIn: amountIn,
    amountOutMinimum: 0,
    sqrtPriceLimitX96: 0
  });
}

Step 3: Execute and Capture State Changes

Run the simulation and meticulously record all pre- and post-state differences.

Detailed Instructions

Execute your script against the forked network and implement a comprehensive state snapshot system. Before running the transaction sequence, record the balances of all relevant tokens (e.g., ETH, USDC, governance tokens) for your address and any involved smart contracts. After execution, take another snapshot and calculate the delta (difference) for each asset. Pay special attention to impermanent loss metrics if modifying liquidity provider (LP) positions, and track gas consumption estimates for each step. Use your framework's built-in gas reporter or a tool like eth-gas-reporter.

Sub-step 1: Deploy a helper contract or use a library like snapshot.js to record ERC-20 balances via the balanceOf function.
Sub-step 2: Run the main simulation script using npx hardhat run scripts/simulate.js --network hardhat.
Sub-step 3: Immediately after execution, call the snapshot function again to capture the final state.
Sub-step 4: Subtract the initial balances from the final balances to generate a clear change report.

Tip: For complex multi-step transactions, take intermediate snapshots after each major operation (e.g., after a swap, before a deposit) to isolate the impact of individual actions.

javascript
// Balance snapshot function example
async function takeSnapshot(signerAddress) {
  const tokens = {
    WETH: "0xC02aaA39b223FE8D0A0e5C4F27eAD9083C756Cc2",
    USDC: "0xA0b86991c6218b36c1d19D4a2e9Eb0cE3606eB48"
  };
  let snapshot = {};
  for (const [name, address] of Object.entries(tokens)) {
    const contract = new ethers.Contract(address, ["function balanceOf(address) view returns (uint256)"], ethers.provider);
    snapshot[name] = await contract.balanceOf(signerAddress);
  }
  return snapshot;
}

Step 4: Analyze Results and Refine Strategy

Evaluate the simulation's output to assess viability and optimize the transaction plan.

Detailed Instructions

Analyze the captured data to make a data-driven go/no-go decision. Calculate key performance indicators such as the net portfolio value change, transaction cost efficiency (gas fees vs. value gained), and slippage incurred during swaps. Compare the outcome against alternative strategies—for instance, using a different DEX aggregator like 1inch (0x1111111254EEB25477B68fb85Ed929f73A960582) or adjusting the order of operations. This is where you perform sensitivity analysis by re-running the simulation with different parameters (e.g., 5% more input capital, 0.5% higher slippage tolerance).

Sub-step 1: Convert all balance deltas to a common denomination (e.g., USD) using price oracles from the simulation block.
Sub-step 2: Summarize the total gas used and estimate the mainnet cost at a gas price of, for example, 30 Gwei.
Sub-step 3: Identify any unexpected reverts, failed transactions, or suboptimal rates from the event logs.
Sub-step 4: Based on the analysis, adjust your script's parameters or logic and loop back to Step 2 for a new simulation run.

Tip: Create a simple dashboard or spreadsheet template to compare multiple simulation runs side-by-side, highlighting the strategy with the best risk-adjusted return.

javascript
// Example analysis logic
const ethPrice = 1800; // USD per ETH, fetched from an oracle
const gasPrice = 30e9; // 30 Gwei in wei
const totalGasUsed = 250000; // from receipt
const gasCostInETH = (totalGasUsed * gasPrice) / 1e18;
const gasCostUSD = gasCostInETH * ethPrice;
console.log(`Estimated transaction cost: $${gasCostUSD.toFixed(2)}`);
// Compare this cost against the portfolio value increase from the snapshot delta.

Comparing Simulation Tool Approaches

Comparison of methods for simulating portfolio changes to assess impact before execution.

Feature	Option A: In-House Spreadsheet	Option B: Third-Party API	Option C: Dedicated Portfolio Simulator
Setup Time	2-4 weeks for model build	1-2 days for API integration	Immediate (cloud platform)
Cost (Annual)	$5,000 (internal labor)	$15,000 license + $0.05 per API call	$25,000 flat enterprise fee
Data Refresh Rate	Manual daily upload	Real-time (15-min delay)	Real-time (streaming)
Scenario Limit	10 predefined scenarios	Unlimited via API parameters	100 concurrent live scenarios
Risk Metrics Included	VaR (95%), Sharpe Ratio	VaR (95%, 99%), Max Drawdown	Full suite (VaR, CVaR, Stress Tests, Greeks)
Asset Coverage	Equities, ETFs only	Equities, ETFs, Mutual Funds	All (Equities, Bonds, Options, Futures, Crypto)
Backtesting Window	5 years historical	20 years historical	Customizable (up to 30 years)
Execution Integration	Manual trade ticket entry	Automated via FIX protocol	Direct OMS/EMS integration with pre-trade checks

Simulation for Different Strategy Types

Understanding Portfolio Simulation

Portfolio simulation is a crucial risk management tool that allows you to test how your investment strategy would perform under different market conditions without risking real capital. Think of it as a financial flight simulator for your crypto assets.

Why Simulate First?

Risk Assessment: See potential losses before they happen. For example, simulate a large trade on Uniswap V3 to check for slippage and impermanent loss.
Strategy Validation: Test if your planned Dollar-Cost Averaging (DCA) schedule on Aave or Compound would have been profitable over the last year.
Fee Optimization: Discover how network gas fees on Ethereum or alternative Layer 2s like Arbitrum impact your final returns when executing complex multi-step DeFi transactions.

Practical First Steps

Start by using free, visual tools like DeFi Llama's simulator or Token Terminal. Connect a read-only wallet to see your current holdings, then model adding a new liquidity pool position on Curve Finance. The simulation will show estimated APY, potential impermanent loss scenarios, and how your portfolio's composition changes.

SECTION-FAQ-DEEP-DIVE

How to Simulate Portfolio Changes Before Executing

How to Simulate Portfolio Changes Before Executing

Core Concepts of Portfolio Simulation

Scenario Analysis

Monte Carlo Simulation

Asset Correlation Modeling

Rebalancing Strategy Simulation

Liquidity & Cash Flow Modeling

A Practical Simulation Workflow

Step 1: Establish a Local Test Environment

Detailed Instructions

Step 2: Script the Portfolio Interaction

Detailed Instructions

Step 3: Execute and Capture State Changes

Detailed Instructions

Step 4: Analyze Results and Refine Strategy

Detailed Instructions

Comparing Simulation Tool Approaches

Simulation for Different Strategy Types

Understanding Portfolio Simulation

Why Simulate First?

Practical First Steps

Technical Limitations and Edge Cases

Further Reading and Tools

Tenderly Simulation Documentation

DeFi Saver Simulator

Portfolio Visualizer

Backtesting.py Documentation

Let's bring your Web3 vision to life.