A foundational guide to the essential metrics used to analyze, compare, and navigate the decentralized finance ecosystem, providing clarity on protocol health, user adoption, and market dynamics.
LABS
Understanding Total Value Locked (TVL) and Other DeFi Metrics
Chainscore © 2025
The Core DeFi Metrics Framework
Total Value Locked (TVL)
Total Value Locked (TVL) represents the total capital deposited in a DeFi protocol's smart contracts. It's the primary gauge of a protocol's size and user trust.
- Calculated by summing all crypto assets staked, lent, or pooled in a protocol.
- Example: Aave's TVL includes all supplied assets available for borrowing.
- A high TVL generally indicates strong liquidity and perceived security, but it should be analyzed alongside other metrics for a complete picture.
Annual Percentage Yield (APY)
Annual Percentage Yield (APY) measures the real rate of return earned on an investment over a year, accounting for the effect of compounding interest or rewards.
- Can be variable, based on protocol supply/demand dynamics.
- Example: Earning 5% APY on a stablecoin pool in Curve Finance.
- This metric is crucial for users to compare the earning potential and sustainability of different yield-generating strategies across platforms.
Trading Volume
Trading Volume quantifies the total value of assets swapped on a decentralized exchange (DEX) or aggregator over a specific period.
- High volume signals strong liquidity, reducing slippage for traders.
- Example: Uniswap's daily volume across all its pools.
- Consistent high volume is a key indicator of a protocol's utility, fee generation potential, and its role as a core market liquidity hub.
Unique Active Wallets (UAW)
Unique Active Wallets (UAW) tracks the number of distinct wallet addresses interacting with a protocol's smart contracts, serving as a proxy for user adoption and engagement.
- Measures daily, weekly, or monthly active users.
- Example: Tracking how many wallets supplied assets to Compound in a month.
- Growing UAW indicates expanding reach and network effects, though it doesn't equate to unique individuals due to multi-wallet usage.
Protocol Revenue & Fees
Protocol Revenue is the fee income retained by the protocol treasury after distributing rewards to liquidity providers. Fees are the total charges paid by users for services.
- Revenue sustainability is key for long-term protocol development.
- Example: Lido's revenue from staking service fees on Ethereum.
- Analyzing fees and revenue reveals the economic viability and value capture mechanism of a DeFi business model.
Collateralization Ratio
Collateralization Ratio measures the value of collateral backing borrowed assets in lending protocols, critical for assessing systemic risk and liquidation thresholds.
- A higher ratio means a safer, less risky loan position.
- Example: A 150% ratio on a MakerDAO Vault backing a DAI loan.
- This metric is vital for understanding the health of the lending market and the stability of algorithmic stablecoins like DAI.
Deconstructing Total Value Locked (TVL)
A step-by-step guide to understanding TVL and other key DeFi metrics, from raw data to critical analysis.
1
Define and Locate TVL Data
Understand what TVL measures and where to find the raw data.
Detailed Instructions
Total Value Locked (TVL) is the aggregate value of all crypto assets deposited in a decentralized finance (DeFi) protocol. It is a key, but often misunderstood, metric for gauging protocol size and user trust. It's calculated by summing the dollar value of all assets staked, lent, or provided as liquidity. To begin your analysis, you must locate reliable data sources.
- Sub-step 1: Use Aggregators: Visit sites like DeFi Llama (defillama.com) or DeFi Pulse. For example, check Ethereum's total TVL at
https://defillama.com/chain/Ethereum. - Sub-step 2: Query On-Chain: For a specific protocol like Aave, you can query a blockchain explorer. Use a call to the pool's contract to get total supply figures.
- Sub-step 3: Note the Calculation Method: Determine if the TVL is calculated using a time-weighted average price or a spot price from an oracle like Chainlink, as this affects volatility.
Tip: TVL is a lagging indicator and can be inflated by double-counting when protocols integrate (e.g., a yield aggregator depositing into a lending market).
2
Decompose TVL into Core Components
Break down a protocol's TVL into its constituent assets and pools.
Detailed Instructions
A single TVL figure is a sum of values across multiple liquidity pools, lending markets, or staking contracts. To understand the health and risks, you must decompose it. For a decentralized exchange (DEX) like Uniswap V3 on Ethereum, this means examining individual pools.
- Sub-step 1: Identify Major Pools: On DeFi Llama's protocol page, find the 'Pools' tab. For Uniswap, the largest pool is often WETH/USDC.
- Sub-step 2: Analyze Token Composition: Note the percentage of TVL in stablecoins (e.g., USDC, DAI) versus volatile assets (e.g., ETH, WBTC). A high stablecoin ratio may indicate a preference for lower-risk farming.
- Sub-step 3: Check Pool-Specific Metrics: For the WETH/USDC 0.05% fee pool at address
0x88e6A0c2dDD26FEEb64F039a2c41296FcB3f5640, review the individual token reserves and current liquidity concentration ticks.
Tip: A protocol overly reliant on one or two pools for its TVL is more susceptible to liquidity crises if those pools experience impermanent loss or a token crash.
3
Contextualize with Complementary Metrics
Move beyond TVL by analyzing revenue, fees, and active users.
Detailed Instructions
TVL alone does not indicate protocol success or sustainability. You must contextualize it with metrics that show economic activity and value capture. Protocol Revenue (fees accrued to token holders) and Fees Generated (total user-paid fees) are crucial.
- Sub-step 1: Calculate Revenue-to-TVL Ratio: If a protocol has $5B TVL and generates $50M in annualized revenue, its revenue/TVL ratio is 1%. Compare this across similar protocols (e.g., Lido vs. Rocket Pool).
- Sub-step 2: Analyze Daily Active Users (DAU): Use Dune Analytics dashboards. A high TVL with low DAU suggests passive, "sticky" capital rather than active engagement.
- Sub-step 3: Examine Fee Sources: For a lending protocol like Compound, distinguish between interest spread revenue and liquidation fees. Query the
Comptrollercontract forprotocolSeizeShareMantissa, often set to a value like2.8e16(2.8%).
Tip: A protocol with modest TVL but high revenue and user growth may be healthier than one with massive, stagnant TVL.
4
Identify Risks and Limitations of TVL
Critically assess how TVL can be manipulated or provide a misleading picture.
Detailed Instructions
The final step is a critical evaluation of TVL's shortcomings. TVL is not a measure of profitability or security. It can be artificially inflated through incentives, double-counted, or concentrated in high-risk assets.
- Sub-step 1: Check for Incentive Dependence: Look for high emission rates of governance tokens. If 40% of a pool's yield comes from
XYZtoken emissions, the TVL may flee when emissions slow. - Sub-step 2: Audit for Double-Counting: When a yield aggregator (e.g., Yearn) deposits funds in a lending protocol (e.g., Aave), the same assets can appear in both protocols' TVL. Manually trace large deposits.
- Sub-step 3: Assess Collateral Quality: In lending protocols, a high TVL composed largely of a volatile, low-liquidity token (e.g., a memecoin with a 50% collateral factor) is riskier than one using ETH or stablecoins. Review the
collateralFactorMantissafor specific markets in Compound'sComptroller.
Tip: Always pair TVL analysis with an audit of the protocol's smart contracts and a review of its governance decisions to get a complete risk profile.
Metric Comparison: TVL vs. Volume vs. Revenue
Key metrics for evaluating DeFi protocol performance and adoption, using Ethereum L2 Arbitrum as an example.
| Metric | Total Value Locked (TVL) | Daily Volume | Daily Revenue |
|---|---|---|---|
Definition | Total capital deposited in protocol smart contracts | Total value of all transactions processed | Fees collected by the protocol from users |
Primary Use | Measures protocol adoption and security | Measures user activity and utility | Measures protocol profitability and sustainability |
Typical Unit | USD | USD | USD |
Example (Arbitrum, Apr 2024) | $2.85 Billion | $1.2 Billion | $1.1 Million |
Volatility | Generally stable, changes with deposits/withdrawals | Highly volatile, spikes with market activity | Moderately volatile, correlates with volume |
Leading Indicator For | Network security and long-term confidence | Short-term user engagement and liquidity | Protocol's business model viability |
Key Limitation | Can be inflated by double-counting or incentives | Does not distinguish user count or transaction type | Can be low for protocols prioritizing growth over profit |
Analyst Perspectives: Applying the Metrics
Understanding TVL Fundamentals
Total Value Locked (TVL) is the cornerstone metric for gauging the health and adoption of a DeFi protocol. It represents the total value of all crypto assets deposited by users into its smart contracts. Think of it as the protocol's 'assets under management.' A higher TVL generally signals greater user trust and liquidity, but it's not the only indicator of success.
Key Points to Remember
- TVL is dynamic: It fluctuates with both the price of the locked assets (like ETH or stablecoins) and user deposit/withdrawal activity. A rising TVL could mean new users or simply a crypto bull market.
- Beyond TVL: Also watch Daily Active Users (DAU) and protocol revenue. A protocol like Aave can have a massive TVL, but its health is better assessed by how many users are actively borrowing and paying interest.
- Use case: Investors use TVL to compare the scale and market dominance of protocols. For example, comparing the TVL of Lido (for staking) versus MakerDAO (for borrowing) shows where capital is concentrated in different DeFi sectors.
A Practical Framework for Protocol Analysis
A structured process for understanding Total Value Locked (TVL) and other key DeFi metrics to evaluate protocol health and risk.
1
Define and Source the Core Metrics
Identify the primary metrics for analysis and locate reliable data sources.
Detailed Instructions
Begin by defining the key metrics for your analysis. Total Value Locked (TVL) is the aggregate value of all assets deposited in a protocol's smart contracts, serving as a primary indicator of size and user trust. However, it must be analyzed alongside other metrics like Protocol Revenue (fees accrued to the protocol), Treasury Health (the protocol's own asset reserves), and User Activity (unique active wallets, transaction counts).
- Sub-step 1: Use aggregated data platforms like DeFiLlama or Token Terminal to get a high-level, cross-protocol view of TVL and revenue trends.
- Sub-step 2: For on-chain granularity, query subgraphs for protocols like Aave or Uniswap V3. For example, to get the latest TVL for Aave V3 on Ethereum, you might query its hosted service subgraph.
- Sub-step 3: Cross-reference data with the protocol's own analytics dashboard and official documentation to understand how they calculate their metrics, as methodologies can differ.
Tip: TVL can be inflated by double-counting (e.g., LP tokens deposited in another protocol) or high yields from inflationary tokens. Always check the underlying asset composition.
2
Decompose and Analyze TVL Composition
Break down TVL into its constituent assets and pools to assess concentration and quality.
Detailed Instructions
Raw TVL is a blunt instrument. True insight comes from analyzing its composition. A protocol with 90% of its TVL in a single, volatile altcoin is riskier than one with a diversified basket of blue-chip assets like ETH, stablecoins (USDC, DAI), and wBTC. Examine the distribution across different pools or vaults.
- Sub-step 1: On DeFiLlama, navigate to the specific protocol page and review the 'Chains' and 'Tokens' tabs to see TVL distribution.
- Sub-step 2: For a specific pool (e.g., a Uniswap V3 ETH/USDC pool), use a block explorer to inspect the pool contract and check token balances. Use Etherscan's 'Read Contract' function on the pool address
0x88e6A0c2dDD26FEEb64F039a2c41296FcB3f5640to callliquidity()andslot0()to get current liquidity and price. - Sub-step 3: Calculate the percentage dominance of the top 3 assets. A figure over 70% indicates high concentration risk. Also, note if TVL is dominated by the protocol's own native token, which can be a red flag.
Tip: Use
curlto fetch pool data from a public node:curl -X POST https://eth-mainnet.g.alchemy.com/v2/your-api-key -H "Content-Type: application/json" -d '{"jsonrpc":"2.0","method":"eth_call","params":[{"to": "0x88e6A0c2dDD26FEEb64F039a2c41296FcB3f5640", "data": "0x0902f1ac"}, "latest"],"id":1}'This callsgetReserves()on a Uniswap V2-style pair.
3
Contextualize with Ratio and Growth Analysis
Evaluate TVL and revenue through comparative ratios and growth trends over time.
Detailed Instructions
Absolute numbers are less meaningful than ratios and trends. Calculate the Protocol Revenue to TVL Ratio (Annualized Revenue / TVL) to gauge efficiency and yield generation for the protocol itself. A low ratio may suggest the protocol is not effectively monetizing its locked capital. Also, analyze TVL Growth Rate week-over-week or month-over-month.
- Sub-step 1: On Token Terminal, chart 'Fees' and 'TVL' for the protocol over a 180-day period. Observe if revenue growth outpaces TVL growth.
- Sub-step 2: Compute the annualized revenue/TVL ratio manually. If a protocol has $500M TVL and generated $5M in fees last month, its monthly ratio is 1% ($5M/$500M). Annualized, this is approximately 12% (1% * 12).
- Sub-step 3: Compare this ratio to sector benchmarks. For example, leading DEXs might have ratios between 5-15%, while lending protocols may be lower. A sudden spike in TVL without corresponding revenue growth could indicate a short-term incentive program (liquidity mining) rather than organic use.
Tip: Use the Price-to-Sales (P/S) ratio (Fully Diluted Valuation / Annualized Revenue) for a token-based valuation perspective. A P/S > 100 is often considered high for mature protocols.
4
Stress Test with Scenario and Dependency Analysis
Model the impact of market shocks and assess external dependencies and risks.
Detailed Instructions
The final step is forward-looking. Stress test the protocol's metrics under adverse conditions. Model a 40% drop in the price of its dominant collateral asset. How would TVL and, more critically, solvency (for lending protocols) be affected? Also, map out protocol dependencies on oracles (e.g., Chainlink), bridges, and other infrastructure.
- Sub-step 1: For a lending protocol like Compound, use a simplified model. If $300M of a $500M TVL is in ETH collateral, a 40% ETH price drop reduces that collateral value to $180M, potentially triggering liquidations if loans are undercollateralized.
- Sub-step 2: Check oracle configurations. Verify the main price feed for a vault by reading the
oracle()function on the vault's smart contract (e.g.,0x5f18C75AbDAe578b483E5F43f12a39cF75b973a9for a Yearn vault). - Sub-step 3: Analyze TVL Stickiness. Review historical data for periods of market stress (e.g., May 2022, November 2022). Did TVL plummet more or less than the broader market? High stickiness suggests resilient, long-term users.
Tip: Incorporate Smart Contract Risk metrics from platforms like Immunefi (bug bounty size, past hacks) and Gauntlet (risk parameter simulations) into your final assessment framework.
SECTION-FAQ-LIMITATIONS
FAQ: Limitations and Common Misconceptions
Further Reading and Data Sources
Ready to Start Building?
Let's bring your Web3 vision to life.
From concept to deployment, ChainScore helps you architect, build, and scale secure blockchain solutions.