Tally's Delegate System vs Boardroom's Delegate Dashboard: Delegate Engagement

Structured reputation system: Features verified delegate profiles with voting history, statements, and delegated voting power (e.g., 2.5M UNI for top delegates). This matters for token holders seeking alignment who want to research and delegate to experts based on transparent track records.

Flexible voting power management: Supports partial delegation (split voting power) and topic-based delegation (delegate by category like Treasury or Security). This matters for sophisticated institutions requiring granular control over how their governance influence is applied.

End-to-end proposal workflow: Guides users from temperature check → governance proposal → on-chain execution. Integrated with Snapshot for signaling and Safe for execution. This matters for DAO contributors and project founders actively steering protocol upgrades and treasury management.

Proactive governance intelligence: Custom alerts for new proposals, voting deadlines, and delegate activity changes across all connected protocols. This matters for active participants who cannot manually monitor dozens of DAO forums and Snapshot spaces, preventing missed votes.

Direct smart contract interaction: Tally's system is built directly on top of governance contracts (e.g., Compound Governor Bravo, Uniswap). This enables real-time vote delegation and execution without intermediary layers. This matters for protocols requiring maximum security and transparency, as delegate actions are verifiable on-chain.

Centralized reputation hub: Tally aggregates delegate profiles, voting history, and statements across multiple protocols (Compound, Uniswap, Gitcoin) into a single interface. This provides cross-protocol reputation visibility, helping token holders identify and delegate to consistent, high-quality delegates. This matters for large token holders (DAOs, VCs) managing governance across their portfolio.

Aggregated cross-chain view: Boardroom supports governance across Ethereum, Polygon, Arbitrum, and 10+ other chains in one dashboard. This provides a unified management console for delegates and voters active in multi-chain ecosystems (e.g., Aave, Balancer, Lido). This matters for delegates operating across Layer 2s and sidechains who need to track proposals without switching interfaces.

Flexible delegation controls: Offers features like partial delegation splits (e.g., 60% to Delegate A, 40% to Delegate B) and proposal-type-specific delegation. This enables sophisticated voting strategies beyond all-or-nothing delegation. This matters for institutional delegators and DAO treasuries seeking to mitigate concentration risk and align delegates with specific expertise areas.

Limited multi-chain support: Tally's primary strength is deep integration with major Ethereum Mainnet governance systems. Support for Layer 2 and alternative chain governance (e.g., Polygon, Avalanche) is less mature or requires custom integration. This matters for protocols native to other chains or deploying governance on L2s for cost savings.

Additional trust assumption: Boardroom acts as an aggregation and indexing layer, which can introduce data latency or centralization points compared to direct on-chain interaction. While secure, it adds a dependency on Boardroom's indexers for proposal and vote state. This matters for maximalist protocols where every component must be trust-minimized and verifiable.

Native multi-chain support for Compound, Uniswap, and ENS governance contracts. This matters for DAOs that require direct, low-latency interaction with their core protocol's on-chain voting mechanisms, minimizing abstraction layers.

Granular delegate profiles with historical voting power, proposal alignment scores, and delegation trends. This matters for token holders performing due diligence, as it provides transparent, on-chain reputation metrics beyond simple vote counts.

Primarily a front-end for existing contracts (e.g., Governor Bravo). This matters for DAOs needing bespoke governance modules, custom delegation logic, or deep brand integration, as Tally's framework is less flexible than a full-stack solution.

Aggregated dashboard for tracking delegations and proposals across 30+ protocols like Aave, Compound, and Lido from a single interface. This matters for professional delegates or funds managing voting power across a diversified portfolio, saving significant operational overhead.

Features like delegation statements, sub-delegation, and gasless voting via EIP-712 signatures. This matters for increasing voter participation and enabling sophisticated delegation strategies without requiring constant wallet interaction from token holders.

Additional dependency on Boardroom's indexing and aggregation services. This matters for DAOs prioritizing maximum decentralization and direct contract interaction, as it introduces a trusted intermediary layer for data presentation and vote bundling.