Public mempools are a performance tax. Every pending transaction broadcasts its intent, creating a zero-sum game for MEV extraction that inflates user costs and clogs network throughput.
future-of-dexs-amms-orderbooks-and-aggregators
Blog
Why Privacy is the Missing Layer for DEX Scalability
We argue that privacy is not a luxury for DEXs but a prerequisite for scaling. By moving order flow and computation off-chain, privacy protocols like Penumbra and Aztec enable batch processing and state compression that public AMMs cannot achieve.
introduction
THE BLIND SPOT
Introduction
Public mempools and transparent execution are a systemic bottleneck, not just a privacy concern.
Privacy enables parallel execution. Obfuscated transaction details, as pioneered by Aztec and Penumbra, allow validators to process orders without front-running, unlocking true scalability.
Transparency creates congestion. The Ethereum mempool's visibility forces sequencers like those on Arbitrum to serialize blocks defensively, capping TPS far below theoretical limits.
Evidence: Flashbots data shows over 90% of Ethereum blocks contain MEV, directly linking public data to latency and fee inefficiency.
thesis-statement
THE STATE BOTTLENECK
The Core Argument: Privacy Enables Compression
Public on-chain state growth is the fundamental scalability limit for DEXs, which privacy solves by compressing transaction data.
Public state is the bottleneck. Every Uniswap v3 swap broadcasts its intent, bloating the global state that every node must replicate and process, creating a hard scalability ceiling.
Privacy compresses execution. Protocols like Penumbra and Aztec bundle and prove user actions off-chain, submitting only a validity proof, collapsing thousands of intent-based operations into a single state update.
This is not just encryption. Unlike Tornado Cash, which hides history, zero-knowledge compression hides the computational path, enabling intent-based architectures like UniswapX to scale without congesting the base layer.
Evidence: StarkEx processes over 9k TPS for dYdX by compressing trades into validity proofs, a model any DEX can adopt once privacy is the default for order flow.
key-trends
WHY PRIVATE STATE IS THE NEW MEMPOOL
The Three Scalability Levers of Privacy
Public state is the primary bottleneck for DEX scalability. Privacy isn't just about hiding; it's about compressing and parallelizing the blockchain's workload.
01
The Problem: Public State Congestion
Every DEX swap is a public auction for block space, creating frontrunning, MEV extraction, and network-wide latency. This turns Uniswap and Curve pools into global bottlenecks.
- Eliminates Frontrunning: Private transactions remove the public mempool, the source of ~$1B+ in annual MEV.
- Reduces On-Chain Footprint: Only net settlement hits L1, compressing ~1000 private actions into 1 public state update.
~$1B+
MEV Eliminated
1000:1
State Compression
02
The Solution: Intent-Based Settlement
Privacy enables users to express desired outcomes (intents) off-chain, which are resolved by solvers in a competitive, trust-minimized environment. This is the core innovation behind UniswapX and CowSwap.
- Parallel Execution: Solvers process batches of intents off-chain, bypassing sequential block constraints.
- Optimal Routing: Access to fragmented liquidity across EVM, Solana, and Cosmos without on-chain bridging overhead.
~500ms
Solver Latency
>50%
Fill Rate Boost
03
The Architecture: Encrypted Mempools & ZKPs
Projects like Aztec and Penumbra use encrypted mempools and zero-knowledge proofs to decouple execution from verification. This separates the scalability problem into two tractable parts.
- Local Execution: Transaction logic runs client-side or in a co-processor, not on-chain.
- Global Verification: The chain only validates a ZK-SNARK proof (~1KB) of correct private state transition.
~1KB
Proof Size
10,000+ TPS
Theoretical Capacity
WHY PRIVACY IS THE MISSING LAYER
Scalability Trade-Offs: Public vs. Private DEX Architecture
Compares the fundamental architectural constraints and scaling vectors of transparent DEXs versus privacy-preserving alternatives, quantifying the performance and cost trade-offs.
| Scalability Vector | Public DEX (e.g., Uniswap v3, Curve) | Private DEX (e.g., Penumbra, Elixir) | Intent-Based/Off-Chain (e.g., UniswapX, CowSwap) |
|---|---|---|---|
State Bloat per User | ~1 KB (LP position) + TX history | ~100 bytes (encrypted note) | 0 bytes (no on-chain user state) |
MEV Resistance | |||
Cross-Chain Swap Latency | ~12 sec (Ethereum L1) to ~2 sec (Solana) | ~12 sec (base layer bound) | < 1 sec (off-chain matching) |
Settlement Cost per User Op | $10-50 (Ethereum L1), $0.01-0.10 (L2) | $15-60 (ZK-proof overhead) | $0 (user), subsidized by filler |
Liquidity Fragmentation | High (per-chain pools) | Low (shielded pool abstraction) | None (aggregates all liquidity) |
Scalability Ceiling | Bottlenecked by base L1/L2 TPS | Bottlenecked by ZK-proof generation | Bottlenecked by off-chain solver competition |
Composability with DeFi Legos | Conditional (via intents) |
deep-dive
THE LEAK
Mechanics: From Leaky Mempools to Batch Settlement
Public mempools expose trade intent, creating a toxic environment of MEV extraction that fundamentally limits DEX scalability.
Public mempools are toxic. Every pending transaction broadcasts its intent, inviting front-running and sandwich attacks by bots. This creates a tax on every trade, disincentivizing large orders and fragmenting liquidity.
Privacy enables batch settlement. Protocols like UniswapX and CowSwap use off-chain order matching and intent-based architectures. This aggregates trades into a single, settled batch, eliminating the granular, leaky mempool.
Batch settlement scales. A single batch settlement transaction on Ethereum can clear thousands of matched orders, compressing volume. This is the core scaling mechanism for Across Protocol and layerzero-based cross-chain intents.
Evidence: In Q1 2024, over 60% of Uniswap's volume on Ethereum was settled via its private RFQ system, not its public AMM pools, proving demand for leak-proof execution.
counter-argument
THE MEMPOOL LEAK
The Obvious Rebuttal (And Why It's Wrong)
Public mempools expose order flow, creating a front-running tax that directly limits DEX scalability.
Public mempools are toxic. Every swap intent broadcast to Ethereum or Solana is public data. This creates a front-running tax where MEV searchers extract value from every user transaction, increasing effective slippage and suppressing trading volume.
Privacy enables batch execution. Protocols like Penumbra and Aztec demonstrate that hiding transaction details until settlement allows for atomic batch processing. This reduces on-chain contention and increases the viable transactions per block.
Scalability requires state minimization. Current scaling via Arbitrum or zkSync optimizes compute and storage, but ignores the state bloat from public intent. Private execution, as seen in Tornado Cash's architecture, minimizes the verifiable state change, which is the ultimate bottleneck.
Evidence: Research from Flashbots shows >90% of DEX trades on Ethereum are vulnerable to some form of MEV extraction. This is a direct, measurable drag on liquidity efficiency and chain throughput that L2s alone do not solve.
risk-analysis
WHY PRIVACY IS THE MISSING LAYER FOR DEX SCALABILITY
The Bear Case: Where This Theory Breaks
Current DEX scaling narratives focus on throughput and cost, but ignore the critical bottleneck of transparent mempools and on-chain state.
01
The Problem: MEV is a Scalability Tax
Transparent mempools turn every trade into a public auction for extractable value. This creates systemic drag on network performance and user economics.\n- Front-running and sandwich attacks extract ~$1B+ annually from traders.\n- Latency races for block builders create centralization pressure and wasted compute.\n- The 'scalability' of a chain is meaningless if its economic throughput is siphoned.
$1B+
Annual Extract
>90%
OFAC-Compliant Blocks
02
The Problem: On-Chain State is a Public Liability
Every DEX interaction permanently leaks trading strategy and wallet composition. This creates a fundamental ceiling for institutional and sophisticated retail adoption.\n- Wallet profiling enables targeted phishing and social engineering attacks.\n- Strategy copying by competitors destroys alpha for funds and DAOs.\n- Compliance and tax reporting become a nightmare with fully transparent P&L.
100%
Strategy Leakage
~0
Institutional DEX Share
03
The Solution: Encrypted Mempools & ZK-Settlements
Privacy must be integrated at the protocol layer, not bolted on via mixers. The endgame is encrypted order flow with zero-knowledge settlement proofs.\n- FHE/MPC-based mempools (e.g., Fhenix, Aztec) hide transaction intent until execution.\n- ZK-proofs of trade execution (like zkSNARKs) can validate outcomes without revealing inputs.\n- This architecture neutralizes MEV at the source and makes state leakage optional.
~0ms
Front-run Latency
Selective
Disclosure
04
The Solution: Intent-Based Architectures with Private Solvers
Move from transaction-based to outcome-based trading. Users submit encrypted intents; off-chain solvers compete privately to fulfill them.\n- UniswapX and CowSwap demonstrate the intent model but lack privacy.\n- Private solvers using Secure Enclaves (e.g., Oasis, Phala) can compute optimal routes confidentially.\n- This shifts the scaling burden to a permissionless off-chain network, not the L1.
10-100x
Route Complexity
Off-Chain
Computation
05
The Problem: Privacy Breaks Composability
DeFi's 'money Lego' superpower relies on transparent state. Private transactions create opaque assets that cannot be natively composed by other smart contracts.\n- A private ERC-20 balance cannot be used as collateral in Aave or MakerDAO.\n- This forces a trade-off: privacy or utility. Most protocols choose utility, killing privacy adoption.\n- The scaling narrative fails if the private ecosystem is a siloed dead end.
Siloed
Liquidity
Limited
Use Cases
06
The Solution: Programmable Privacy & ZK-Proof Aggregation
The answer is not full anonymity, but programmable disclosure. Use zero-knowledge proofs to reveal specific properties of private state for composability.\n- ZK-proofs of solvency allow a private asset to be used as collateral without revealing the amount.\n- ZK-Membership proofs (e.g., Semaphore) enable anonymous governance or airdrop claims.\n- Aggregators like Polygon zkEVM or zkSync could batch private state proofs for efficient verification.
Selective
Composability
Batchable
ZK Proofs
future-outlook
THE MISSING LAYER
The Integrated Stack: Privacy as Foundational Infrastructure
On-chain privacy is not a feature but a prerequisite for scaling decentralized exchange liquidity and user experience.
Public mempools are toxic. Every DEX trade on Ethereum or Solana broadcasts intent, enabling front-running MEV bots to extract billions annually. This forces protocols like UniswapX and CowSwap to build complex off-chain intent-solving systems to hide transactions, adding latency and centralization.
Privacy enables atomic composability. A private state layer, like Aztec or Penumbra, allows multiple dependent operations to execute as a single atomic bundle. This eliminates the risk of sandwich attacks between a swap on Uniswap V3 and a deposit into Aave, creating a seamless DeFi pipeline.
The scaling bottleneck is data availability, not computation. Zero-knowledge proofs (ZKPs) from zkSync and StarkNet compress private transaction verification into a tiny proof. The real constraint is ensuring that encrypted transaction data is available for dispute resolution, which networks like Celestia and EigenDA solve.
Evidence: The 2023 Ethereum MEV extraction totaled over $400M, a direct tax on transparent DEX liquidity. Protocols with built-in privacy, like Penumbra's shielded swaps, demonstrate zero measurable MEV, proving the infrastructure works.
takeaways
PRIVACY AS INFRASTRUCTURE
TL;DR for Protocol Architects
Current DEX designs leak intent, creating MEV and limiting scalability. Privacy isn't a feature; it's a required layer for efficient, fair, and composable liquidity.
01
The Problem: Public Mempools are a Scaling Bottleneck
Every public transaction reveals intent, creating a negative-sum game for users. This directly limits throughput and increases costs for all participants.\n- Frontrunning & Sandwich Attacks extract $1B+ annually from users.\n- Gas Auctions inflate costs by 10-100x during high activity.\n- Order Flow Fragmentation reduces liquidity depth and increases slippage.
$1B+
Annual MEV
10-100x
Gas Spikes
02
The Solution: Encrypted Mempools & Order Flow Auctions
Privacy enables off-chain competition and batch execution, the true path to scaling. This is the core innovation behind protocols like Flashbots SUAVE, CoW Swap, and UniswapX.\n- Intent-Based Routing: Users express desired outcome, solvers compete privately.\n- Batch Auctions: Aggregate liquidity across venues for ~30% better prices.\n- Credible Commitments: Eliminate latency races, enabling cross-chain MEV capture via Across and LayerZero.
~30%
Price Improvement
0ms
Latency Race
03
The Architecture: ZKPs for Scalable State Validation
Zero-Knowledge Proofs move trust from social consensus to cryptographic verification, enabling private, verifiable computation at scale.\n- ZK-Rollups: Private state transitions with ~500ms finality (e.g., Aztec).\n- Proof Aggregation: Batch thousands of private trades into a single on-chain proof, reducing cost per trade by >1000x.\n- Composable Privacy: Enables confidential DeFi legos without leaking strategy.
>1000x
Cost Reduction
~500ms
Finality
04
The Outcome: Unlocking Institutional & Cross-Chain Liquidity
Privacy transforms DEXs from leaky public markets into efficient dark pools with on-chain settlement, attracting institutional capital and unifying fragmented liquidity.\n- Strategy Obfuscation: Enables large trades ($10M+) without market impact.\n- Cross-Chain Atomicity: Private intents enable secure arbitrage across Ethereum, Solana, Avalanche.\n- Regulatory Clarity: Transaction details are hidden, but audit trails via ZKPs remain for compliance.
$10M+
Trade Size
0%
Slippage Leak
ENQUIRY
Get In Touch
today.
Our experts will offer a free quote and a 30min call to discuss your project.
NDA Protected
Confidentiality24h Response
Time to ValueDirectly to Engineering Team
No Sales Fluff10+
Protocols Shipped
$20M+
TVL Overall