Free 30-min Web3 Consultation
Book Consultation
Smart Contract Security Audits
View Audit Services
Custom DeFi Protocol Development
Explore DeFi
Full-Stack Web3 dApp Development
View App Services
Free 30-min Web3 Consultation
Book Consultation
Smart Contract Security Audits
View Audit Services
Custom DeFi Protocol Development
Explore DeFi
Full-Stack Web3 dApp Development
View App Services
Free 30-min Web3 Consultation
Book Consultation
Smart Contract Security Audits
View Audit Services
Custom DeFi Protocol Development
Explore DeFi
Full-Stack Web3 dApp Development
View App Services
Free 30-min Web3 Consultation
Book Consultation
Smart Contract Security Audits
View Audit Services
Custom DeFi Protocol Development
Explore DeFi
Full-Stack Web3 dApp Development
View App Services
web3-social-decentralizing-the-feed
Blog

Why Your Attention Data Deserves a Spot Price

The 'free' social media model is a trillion-dollar accounting fraud. This post argues that real-time, on-chain bidding for user attention and engagement data will create a transparent spot price, forcing a market correction and enabling user-owned data economies on protocols like Farcaster and Lens.

introduction
THE ATTENTION ECONOMY

Introduction: The Trillion-Dollar Accounting Fraud

The digital economy's foundational asset—user attention—is systematically mispriced and misappropriated by centralized platforms.

Your attention is an asset that platforms like Google and Meta monetize directly through advertising, generating over $300B in annual revenue. You are the producer, but they capture the value.

The accounting is fraudulent because your data's value is never recorded on your balance sheet. This creates a multi-trillion-dollar liability on the internet's collective P&L statement.

Blockchain provides the ledger to correct this. Tokenized attention transforms engagement into a verifiable, ownable asset class, similar to how Bitcoin created digital scarcity.

Evidence: The creator economy, powered by platforms like YouTube and TikTok, proves demand for direct monetization, yet creators capture less than 10% of the value their attention generates.

thesis-statement
THE DATA

The Core Argument: Attention is an Underpriced Asset

User attention is the primary input for all digital economies, yet its value is captured by intermediaries instead of its source.

Attention is a data asset with a direct market value. Every click, scroll, and dwell time is a measurable signal of intent and preference that platforms like Google and Meta monetize via advertising auctions.

Current markets are inefficient because the asset's creator is excluded. The user's attention data is aggregated and sold, but the user receives no direct compensation, creating a fundamental mispricing.

Blockchain enables direct valuation by creating a verifiable ownership layer. Protocols like Brave/BAT demonstrate the model, but they tokenize attention after aggregation. The frontier is tokenizing the raw signal itself.

Evidence: The digital ad market is a $600B industry built entirely on this underpriced asset. A user's attention stream is the oil; current platforms are the refineries that capture all the margin.

deep-dive
THE PRICE OF EYEBALLS

Deep Dive: Anatomy of an On-Chain Attention Auction

On-chain attention auctions commoditize user intent, creating a spot price for the most valuable resource in crypto: a user's next action.

Attention is a structured intent. A user's on-chain activity—a pending swap, a wallet connection, a pending signature—is a high-fidelity signal of future economic activity. This signal is more valuable than raw clicks because it has a direct, measurable financial outcome. Protocols like UniswapX and CowSwap already treat this intent as a tradable asset.

Auction mechanics replace gas wars. Instead of users paying gas to front-run transactions, solvers and searchers bid for the right to execute the user's intent. The winning bidder's profit is the extractable value (MEV) from optimally routing the transaction. This flips the economic model: users get paid for their attention, and solvers compete on execution quality.

The spot price is execution alpha. The clearing price of an attention auction is the market's real-time valuation of a user's specific intent within a liquidity environment. This price is a function of liquidity depth, cross-chain arbitrage opportunities, and solver competition. It is the purest measure of on-chain demand.

Evidence: UniswapX's Fill Volume. In Q1 2024, over 60% of Uniswap's volume used its intent-based, auction-powered system. This demonstrates that users rationally choose systems that monetize their attention for them, moving away from the inefficient pay-to-order-flow model of traditional finance.

ATTENTION AS AN ASSET CLASS

Data Highlight: The Implicit vs. Explicit Value of You

Comparing the economic capture of user attention and data across traditional Web2 platforms, early Web3 models, and emerging intent-centric architectures.

Economic DimensionWeb2 Platform (Implicit)Web3 1.0 (Explicit, Inefficient)Intent-Centric Web3 (Explicit, Optimized)

Data Ownership & Portability

Revenue Capture by User

0%

1-5% (via token rewards)

15% (via MEV kickbacks & intent premiums)

Attention Monetization Latency

90 days (ad cycle)

7-30 days (staking/unbonding)

< 1 block (atomic settlement)

Primary Value Extraction Mechanism

Surveillance Capitalism

Speculative Tokenomics

Expressible Preference

Representative Protocols/Entities

Meta, Google

Basic Airdrop Farms, SocialFi v1

UniswapX, CowSwap, Anoma, Flashbots SUAVE

User's Role

Product

Speculator

Principal & Beneficiary

Annual Implied Attention Value/User

$500-$1000 (platform estimate)

$50-$200 (volatile token value)

TBD - Market priced via intent solvers

counter-argument
THE DATA

Counter-Argument: Why This Will Never Work (And Why It Will)

The primary objections to monetizing attention are data intangibility and market creation, but new primitives solve both.

Attention is not a commodity. Critics argue you cannot price a nebulous signal like a 'click'. This fails because on-chain activity is a precise, timestamped, and verifiable commodity. Every wallet interaction on Ethereum or Solana is a measurable unit of intent.

No natural market exists. Unlike oil, there is no spot exchange for 'user engagement'. This is solved by intent-based architectures like UniswapX and CowSwap, which create demand for routing and order flow. They are the first buyers.

Privacy is a deal-breaker. Exposing user graphs invites exploitation. This ignores zero-knowledge proofs and trusted execution environments. Protocols like Aztec and Oasis enable private data computation, separating signal from identity.

Evidence: The MEV market. Extractable value from user transactions already exceeds $1B annually. This proves a liquid market for intent exists; it just flows to searchers and builders instead of users. Tokenizing attention redirects this value stream.

protocol-spotlight
ATTENTION ECONOMY INFRASTRUCTURE

Protocol Spotlight: Who's Building the Plumbing?

Your attention is a high-value, under-monetized asset. These protocols are building the rails to price and settle it.

01

The Problem: Attention is Valuable but Illiquid

Every click, view, and engagement generates data, but users have no direct claim to its value. This data is aggregated and sold by platforms like Google and Meta, creating a $600B+ digital ad market where the user is the product.

  • Data Silos: Your attention is fragmented across platforms with no portable identity.
  • Zero Direct Yield: Users provide the raw material but capture none of the financial upside.
  • Opaque Pricing: The "spot price" of your attention is a black box determined by ad-tech intermediaries.
$600B+
Ad Market
0%
User Share
02

The Solution: Attention Derivatives on EigenLayer

Restaking protocols like EigenLayer enable the creation of new cryptoeconomic systems, or Actively Validated Services (AVS). This is the foundational plumbing for attention markets.

  • Economic Security as a Service: Projects can bootstrap trust by leveraging Ethereum's staked ETH, avoiding the cold-start security problem.
  • Modular Data Markets: AVSs can be specialized data oracles that verify and price attention events (e.g., ad views, content engagement).
  • Settlement Layer: Proven attention claims can become a new asset class, settled directly on L2s like Arbitrum or Optimism.
$15B+
TVL Securing AVSs
50+
AVSs Live/Planned
03

The Application: Grass & The Data Layer

Grass is a live example, building a decentralized network for scraping and labeling public web data. It treats user bandwidth and attention as a monetizable resource.

  • Proof-of-Contribution: Users run a lightweight node, contributing to AI training data collection; their contribution is cryptographically verified.
  • Direct Monetization: Users earn yield (in $GRASS or stablecoins) proportional to their provided bandwidth and uptime.
  • Data Integrity: Leverages a network of nodes (like Wynd) to validate data quality, preventing sybil attacks and ensuring the output is valuable for AI/ML models.
2M+
Network Nodes
24/7
Yield Generation
04

The Settlement: Hyperliquid & On-Chain Perps

Once attention is tokenized as a verifiable yield stream, it needs a financial primitive. Perpetual futures DEXs like Hyperliquid and dYdX provide the venue.

  • Attention Futures: Derivatives markets can emerge to hedge or speculate on the future value of a user's or a cohort's attention yield.
  • Composability: These yield streams can be used as collateral, bundled into structured products, or integrated into DeFi lending markets on Aave.
  • Price Discovery: Continuous on-chain trading establishes a true, transparent spot price for attention-based cash flows.
$5B+
Daily Perp Volume
Real-Time
Price Discovery
05

The Privacy Layer: Aztec & zk-Proofs

Monetizing attention cannot come at the cost of privacy. Zero-knowledge proofs, as implemented by Aztec, Aleo, and Zcash, are non-negotiable.

  • Selective Disclosure: Users can prove they performed a valuable action (e.g., watched a full ad) without revealing their identity or broader browsing history.
  • Compliance-Friendly: zk-proofs enable regulatory compliance (e.g., KYC) while preserving user anonymity, a concept pioneered by Mina Protocol.
  • Trustless Verification: The validity of attention claims can be verified by anyone without trusting a central operator, enabling permissionless markets.
~200ms
zk Proof Gen
Zero Trust
Verification
06

The Aggregator: Karak & Yield Orchestration

The end-state is a fragmented landscape of attention-yielding AVSs. Restaking platforms like Karak and EigenLayer evolve into yield aggregators and risk managers.

  • Single Deposit, Multi-Yield: Users deposit restaked assets once and automatically allocate across the highest-yielding, verified attention AVSs.
  • Slashing Insurance: Aggregators can develop pooled security models to insure users against slashing events on any single AVS.
  • Cross-Chain Portability: Protocols like LayerZero and Axelar enable attention yield streams to be recognized and utilized across any blockchain ecosystem.
Auto-Compound
Yield Strategy
Risk-Managed
AVS Exposure
takeaways
ATTENTION AS INFRASTRUCTURE

Takeaways: The CTO's Cheat Sheet

Your users' attention is a quantifiable, monetizable asset. Here's how to treat it like one.

01

The Problem: Attention is a Black Box

User engagement is a qualitative metric, not a financial primitive. You can't price, hedge, or compose it.

  • Lost Alpha: Engagement signals are siloed within your app.
  • No Interoperability: Attention on your platform can't be used as collateral or proof-of-work elsewhere.
  • Opaque Valuation: You can't benchmark your user's time against a market rate.
0
Liquidity Pools
100%
Siloed
02

The Solution: Attention Futures

Tokenize future attention streams into tradable derivatives, creating a spot price for time.

  • Price Discovery: A live market sets the value of 1 hour of a user's focus.
  • Hedging for Apps: Protocols can short attention futures to mitigate churn risk.
  • Composability: These derivatives become collateral in DeFi protocols like Aave or Compound.
24/7
Market
DeFi
Composable
03

The Mechanism: Proof-of-Attention Consensus

Replace wasteful Proof-of-Work with verifiable cognitive labor. Users stake time, not hash power.

  • Direct Monetization: Users earn yield for focused engagement, not just ad views.
  • Sybil-Resistant: Botting is expensive; it requires real human time.
  • Protocol Security: The network is secured by aggregated attention, creating a novel cryptoeconomic flywheel.
-99.9%
Energy vs PoW
Staked Time
New Collateral
04

The Killer App: Intent-Based Everything

A spot price for attention enables generalized solvers. Users express a goal; a market of solvers competes to fulfill it cheapest.

  • See: UniswapX, CowSwap. This extends to any complex transaction.
  • Efficiency: Solvers bundle and optimize, paying users for their attention/data.
  • User Sovereignty: You sell your intent fulfillment, not your personal data.
~50%
Better Execution
Intent
New Primitive
05

The Hurdle: Privacy-Preserving Proofs

Proving you paid attention without revealing what you saw. This is the core R&D challenge.

  • ZK Tech Required: zkSNARKs (e.g., zkSync) or zk-STARKs to generate private attestations.
  • Selective Disclosure: Users prove engagement metrics to dApps without leaking history.
  • Regulatory Gray Area: Different from selling raw data; selling proof-of-work may face novel scrutiny.
ZKPs
Core Tech
0-Knowledge
Attestation
06

The First Mover: Attention-Based Airdrops

The lowest-friction entry point. Allocate token distributions based on verifiable attention, not just wallets or volume.

  • Superior Targeting: Reward genuine users, not sybil farmers.
  • Built-in Liquidity: Airdrop recipients are pre-qualified attention sellers for your futures market.
  • Network Effect Kickstart: Creates immediate demand for the attention spot price from day one.
10x
Sybil Resistance
Day 1
Liquidity
ENQUIRY

Get In Touch
today.

Our experts will offer a free quote and a 30min call to discuss your project.

NDA Protected
24h Response
Directly to Engineering Team
10+
Protocols Shipped
$20M+
TVL Overall
NDA Protected Directly to Engineering Team
Attention Data Spot Price: The End of 'Free' Web2 | ChainScore Blog