Free 30-min Web3 Consultation
Book Consultation
Smart Contract Security Audits
View Audit Services
Custom DeFi Protocol Development
Explore DeFi
Full-Stack Web3 dApp Development
View App Services
Free 30-min Web3 Consultation
Book Consultation
Smart Contract Security Audits
View Audit Services
Custom DeFi Protocol Development
Explore DeFi
Full-Stack Web3 dApp Development
View App Services
Free 30-min Web3 Consultation
Book Consultation
Smart Contract Security Audits
View Audit Services
Custom DeFi Protocol Development
Explore DeFi
Full-Stack Web3 dApp Development
View App Services
Free 30-min Web3 Consultation
Book Consultation
Smart Contract Security Audits
View Audit Services
Custom DeFi Protocol Development
Explore DeFi
Full-Stack Web3 dApp Development
View App Services
wallet-wars-smart-accounts-vs-embedded-wallets
Blog

Why ERC-4337 Will Render Many Current Standards Obsolete

ERC-4337's native UserOperations fundamentally change transaction semantics, making standards built for EOAs—like EIP-712 and certain multi-sig patterns—legacy infrastructure. This is a technical autopsy.

introduction
THE STANDARDIZATION EVENT

Introduction

ERC-4337's account abstraction model will obsolete current wallet and transaction standards by decoupling logic from execution.

Account abstraction standardizes UX. It replaces fragmented EOA-only logic with a single, programmable smart contract account standard, making wallets like MetaMask's current model a legacy interface.

It obsoletes multi-sig and social recovery. Protocols like Safe and Argent become redundant features, not products, as any 4337 wallet can natively implement these patterns.

Gas sponsorship kills fee tokens. The paymaster mechanism eliminates the need for separate standards (ERC-20 for gas) or side-chains, directly challenging models from Polygon and Arbitrum.

Evidence: Since launch, over 3.6 million UserOperations have been processed, with infrastructure from Stackup and Alchemy proving the network effect is already shifting.

deep-dive
THE STANDARDIZATION SHIFT

Deep Dive: From Signatures to Semantics

ERC-4337's account abstraction framework moves the industry's focus from transaction mechanics to user intent, rendering rigid, single-purpose standards obsolete.

ERC-4337 abstracts the signature. Current standards like EIP-712 (structured signing) and EIP-2612 (gasless approvals) solve singular problems. ERC-4337's UserOperation bundle makes these protocol-level hacks redundant by standardizing intent expression at the account layer.

Smart accounts are the new primitive. A Safe multisig or a Soulbound token contract is a static vessel. An ERC-4337 smart account is a programmable agent. This shift from static ownership to dynamic execution logic invalidates standards built for the former.

Session keys become standard library functions. Gaming and social dApps currently rely on bespoke, insecure key delegation systems. ERC-4337 bakes granular permission scopes and time limits into the account, turning a security nightmare into a wallet feature.

Evidence: The EIP-3074 'sponsorship' standard was abandoned. Its core functionality—sponsored transactions—is a native, more secure subset of ERC-4337's paymaster system, demonstrating how intent-centric design subsumes transaction-centric patches.

ACCOUNT ABSTRACTION STANDARDS

Legacy vs. Native: A Feature Matrix

Comparing the capabilities of legacy EOA-based standards against the native account abstraction provided by ERC-4337.

Feature / MetricLegacy EOA + Meta-TransactionsERC-4337 (Native AA)Decision Implication

Atomic Multi-Operation Bundles

Enables social recovery, batched swaps, and gas sponsorship in one tx.

Non-Custodial Gas Sponsorship

Via relayers (e.g., Gelato, Biconomy)

Native via Paymasters

Removes centralization & censorship risk of 3rd-party relayers.

Signature Abstraction

Limited (EIP-1271)

Fully Flexible (ERC-4337)

Enables quantum-safe sigs, multisig, and device-specific signing.

On-Chain UserOp Mempool

Creates a competitive bundler market, reducing fees vs. private relayers.

Wallet Upgradeability

None (EOA is immutable)

Full (Logic in Smart Contract)

Renders EIP-3074 'auth' and 'invoker' standards obsolete.

Average Gas Overhead

~42k gas for basic transfer

~42k gas for basic transfer

Parity achieved; eliminates the 'gas cost' argument against AA.

Protocol-Level Integration

Ad-hoc (e.g., Uniswap Permit2)

Native via EntryPoint

Renders meta-transaction wrappers like Permit2 redundant.

Formal Security Audit Surface

Relayer logic (off-chain)

EntryPoint & Bundler (on-chain)

Shifts security burden to a single, battle-tested singleton contract.

counter-argument
THE REALITY OF LEGACY SYSTEMS

Counter-Argument: But Migration is Hard

The technical and economic inertia of existing infrastructure is the primary barrier to ERC-4337 adoption, not its technical merits.

Protocols are sticky assets. Migrating a live protocol's user base and liquidity is a multi-year, high-risk operation. Teams like Aave or Compound must rebuild their entire security and UX model.

ERC-4337 breaks fee models. Current gas sponsorship and relay services from Biconomy or Gelato are built for EOAs. Account abstraction's native paymasters make these services redundant.

The cost is operational complexity. Managing smart account key rotation and social recovery is a new attack surface. Projects like Safe have a multi-year headstart on this security posture.

Evidence: The migration from ERC-20 to ERC-777 failed despite superior functionality. Network effects and integrated tooling (like MetaMask) create immense inertia that ERC-4337 must overcome.

takeaways
THE STANDARDS SHIFT

Takeaways for Architects and Investors

ERC-4337's account abstraction model isn't an upgrade; it's a foundational rewrite of user interaction that makes entire categories of existing infrastructure redundant.

01

The End of the EOAs-Only World

Externally Owned Accounts (EOAs) are a security and UX dead-end. ERC-4337's Smart Accounts make seed phrases, gas sponsorship, and batched transactions native protocol features.

  • Key Benefit 1: Eliminates the $1B+ annual loss vector from seed phrase mismanagement.
  • Key Benefit 2: Enables gasless onboarding and session keys, unlocking mainstream adoption.
~0
Seed Phrase Risk
100%
UserOps
02

Paymaster Supremacy Over Gas Tokens

ERC-20 gas tokens (like CHI or GST2) and relay networks were complex workarounds. ERC-4337's native Paymaster contract standardizes fee abstraction.

  • Key Benefit 1: Apps can pay fees in any token (stablecoins, loyalty points) or offer sponsored transactions.
  • Key Benefit 2: Renders the entire gas token meta and custom relayers obsolete, consolidating liquidity and logic.
-100%
Gas Token Utility
Any Token
Fee Payment
03

Bundler Networks vs. Transaction Relayers

Services like Gelato and Biconomy built businesses on relaying meta-transactions. ERC-4337 formalizes this role into permissionless Bundlers, commoditizing the service.

  • Key Benefit 1: Creates a competitive, open market for transaction ordering and inclusion, reducing costs.
  • Key Benefit 2: ~500ms latency for UserOps via mempool competition, matching EOA speeds.
Open Market
Bundling
~500ms
Latency
04

The Smart Account as the New Primitive

Multi-sigs (Gnosis Safe), social recovery wallets, and modular key managers become features, not products. The Smart Account is the base layer.

  • Key Benefit 1: Composability: Recovery logic, spending limits, and 2FA plug into a single account standard.
  • Key Benefit 2: Vendor Lock-in Eradicated: Users own their account logic, not a wallet vendor's proprietary stack.
1
Universal Primitive
0
Vendor Lock-in
05

Aggregators Kill Single-Chain Bridges

Intent-based cross-chain swaps via UniswapX or CowSwap require flexible settlement. ERC-4337 Smart Accounts with signature aggregation are the perfect settlement layer, bypassing asset bridges.

  • Key Benefit 1: Users sign a single intent, aggregators find the best path across LayerZero, Axelar, etc.
  • Key Benefit 2: Reduces bridge TVL risk and eliminates the need for canonical token wrappers on every chain.
1 Signature
Multi-Chain
-70%
Bridge Reliance
06

Audit Surface Consolidation

Today, security is fragmented across wallet apps, relayers, and dApp contracts. ERC-4337 centralizes critical logic into three auditable components: Smart Account, Bundler, Paymaster.

  • Key Benefit 1: Standardized Security Model: One audit for a Smart Account module secures it for all users.
  • Key Benefit 2: Reduces the attack surface from 100s of custom implementations to a few robust, battle-tested contracts.
3 Components
Audit Surface
100x
Security Leverage
ENQUIRY

Get In Touch
today.

Our experts will offer a free quote and a 30min call to discuss your project.

NDA Protected
24h Response
Directly to Engineering Team
10+
Protocols Shipped
$20M+
TVL Overall
NDA Protected Directly to Engineering Team
ERC-4337: The End of EOA-Centric Standards | ChainScore Blog